Search term

Was the operation against the mullahs of the red mosque in islamabad justified?

anum - 2007-07-13 11:36:58 - Current Events

The red mosque issue has divided the pakistani nation. Some support the mullahs while some think that the operation against them was long overdue.What do you ppl think. Was the operation justified in anyway or do you sympathize with the president. Do any of you think that the govt was involved in it or the isi. As you are entitled to your opinion so you are open to all sorts of discussions. A lot of are not aware of the incidence is that why so few ppl have answered.

Best Answer:

Everything should be done to prevent Pakistand becoming a fundamentalist Muslim State. Governments MUST remain secular! For something that does not exist, these 'gods' and the religions that have grown up around them, cause an awful lot of trouble! It really is time the human race gave up this god business. It sustained us when we were largely ignorant of the nature of things, but we have now outgrown these imaginary gods, and we don't need them anymore. The belief in god has served it's purpose, now it's time to let it die.

Answers:

One of the saddest event took place in the form of the Lal Masjid operation, both sides done mistakes: Lal Masjid leaders mistakes: 1-Lal Masjid leaders was making Allah’s home as kidnapping place, which is anti-Islamic. 2- Lal Masjid leaders announced jihad without the permission of the government, which is not Islamic. 3- Lal Masjid leaders tried to made state within state, which is again not Islamic. 4- Lal Masjid leaders wanted the escape route from their crimes, which is again not Islamic. For Mutahida Majlis-e-Amal for leaders like Lal Masjid: Believers, uphold justice. Always bear true witness, even if it be against yourself, your parents, or your relatives—and regardless of whether the person against whom you are speaking is rich or poor. God is close to people regardless of their material circumstances. Do not be led by emotion, as this may cause you to swerve from the truth. If you distort your testimony, or refuse to testify, remember that God is aware of all your actions. -Qur'an, An-Nisa, Surah 4:135 Tell all people to read and understand it between the lines, IT MEANS IF A PERSON WHO HAS BEARED DONE MISTAKE WITH A NON-MUSLIM WILL HAVE TO PAY THE PENALTY, Allah call himself as “ RAAB-UL-ALAMEEN “ means “ MAKER OF THE UNIVERSE “(Means Maker of everything in the Universe) and call Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) as “REHMAT-UL-ALAMEEN” means “ BLESSING FOR THE UNIVERSE “(Not only 4 Muslims but 4 everything in the Universe). 5- Lal Masjid leaders lied so many times, e.g.: At first they absolutely denied about weapons any sort of weapons, then at least they retreated from that position after killing a ranger the operation started. Which is again not Islamic. 6- Lal Masjid leaders change their stance so many times. Which is again not Islamic. Now government or in reality President Musharraf blunders: 1- President let the problem escalate unimaginable, e.g.: i-Kidnapping not only of foreigners but also of Police men now tell me which government in the world could forgive it, but Pakistani government did, ii-capturing library, iii- Doing constructions without government permission. 2- I heard on Geo news the conversation between Tariq Azim and Lal Masjid leader, where Tariq Azim categorically said “YES” to foreigners issue, then why Tariq Azim who is democratically elected person’s “YES” was kicked out by dictator President Musharraf, I think president Bush must have made a phone call to him. 3- When government was holding its troops outside of the Lal Masjid for 8 days then why all of a sudden one of the government negotiator after changing the deal courtesy President Musharraf said you just have 15 minutes to agree. 4- Government or in reality President Musharraf certainly could have beat Lal Masjid leaders on the basis of religion, since Lal Masjid leaders case on how to implement ISLAM was very very weak. But President Musharraf thought otherwise. 5- After hearing that conversation between Tariq Azim and Lal Masjid leader, I think the whole responsibility of the ONE OF THE SADDEST INCIDENT IN THE HISTORY OF PAKISTAN is now on President Musharraf. If Tariq Azim had no importane then if President Musharraf was sincere should have talked to Masjid leader directly, but proud,uppish,haughty President Musharraf did not, now tell me what it indicates? After hearing that conversation between Tariq Azim and Lal Masjid leader, It became evident that those ulemas who went inside for talks were either not listening the conversation or they had problems with hearing, since they said foreigners issue was not raised. And to me all who died either rangers or and Lal Masjid rebels both are SHAHEED, since there were confusions who was right who is not, but President Musharraf is the true culprit. May Allah help guide us all, Amen’.

if they had put all the mullahs of the world in this mosque and than drop a dirty bomb on it, the world would today be a truly better place to live in.

I believe it was fully, just because Pakistan's government doesn't want to be overrun by the extremist threat. Pakistan must maintain its government right now, especially because they have close to 30 nuclear weapons. Too bad extremists know how to use propaganda so well though, because they have probably done some real recruiting as a result of this clash. There have also been a few bombings in Pakistan killing like 70 people as a result of this in Pakistan.

well i dont know the pakistan govt to take a side but i think looking at the story pak president did not have any other way he had to do what he did. the terrorists will target anyone that are helping the american.

Everything should be done to prevent Pakistand becoming a fundamentalist Muslim State. Governments MUST remain secular! For something that does not exist, these 'gods' and the religions that have grown up around them, cause an awful lot of trouble! It really is time the human race gave up this god business. It sustained us when we were largely ignorant of the nature of things, but we have now outgrown these imaginary gods, and we don't need them anymore. The belief in god has served it's purpose, now it's time to let it die.